Emmerdale Spoilers: John Has a Terrifying Conversation with Aaron After the Body is Found—”Have You Killed Someone Before?” After Anthony’s death, John’s unsettling advice on handling the body leaves Aaron terrified. Could John Sugden be hiding a deadly past? Emmerdale fans have theories!
Aaron Confesses to John After Anthony’s Death
In an intense episode of Emmerdale (January 23), Anthony Fox meets a grim end following a confrontation with Aaron Dingle. Anthony, exposed as a child abuser who tormented his daughter Ruby, taunted Aaron about his own traumatic past.
Overwhelmed by anger, Aaron violently attacked Anthony at Caleb’s depot. Although Anthony was alive when Aaron left, he returned home in shock, confessing to his boyfriend, John Sugden, that he “nearly killed him.”
John, calm and calculating, insisted they return to the depot. Upon arrival, they discovered Anthony dead. With chilling composure, John took control, demanding they dispose of the body and erase any evidence to protect Aaron.
Read More:
- Megan Fox couldn’t “stop laughing” as she revealed her youngest son, Journey River Green, “burst into tears” upon learning she was pregnant with her fourth child with fiancé MGK. Why?
- VIDEO: Meghan Trainor nearly “turned into a statue” as she made her first appearance with a “Botox-overdone” face.
- Money is just material. Snoop Dogg didn’t hesitate to spend a MASSIVE seven-figure sum as a “wedding gift” for his daughter who had suffered a “stroke.”
Fans Question John’s Mysterious Past
While John’s actions were framed as protective, his cold demeanor raised eyebrows among Emmerdale fans. John, a former army member with a mysterious backstory, has sparked fan theories that he may be more dangerous than he appears.
On social media, viewers expressed suspicions about John’s true nature:
One fan on X (formerly Twitter) wrote, “I’m waiting for John to be a serial killer. The way he spoke to Aaron was creepy. Aaron and John don’t feel convincing as a couple. #Emmerdale.”
Another added, “Here’s why I think John is the killer—not just of Anthony, but maybe others. He’s vengeful and hiding something dark from his past.”
Reddit users also compared John’s character to a manipulative killer from Hollyoaks:
“John’s behavior reminds me of Jez in Hollyoaks. Is he eliminating anyone who threatens Aaron or the Sugden family?”
Aaron Questions John’s Chilling Composure
In a gripping moment, Aaron, panicked over their actions, asked John: “Have you killed someone before?” John’s cryptic response left Aaron—and fans—shaken.
This interaction has fueled further speculation that John may have a violent history, possibly tied to his military background. As John works to cover up Anthony’s death, Aaron is left grappling with fear and doubt about the man he loves.
Read More:
- Taylor Swift couldn’t hide her excitement as she subtly hinted at the “wedding” day between her and Travis Kelce after a family meeting during Thanksgiving.
- VIDEO: Jennifer Lopez left fans worried with her “worn-out” appearance when she made her first public outing with her daughter Emme, following the moment she witnessed Ben Affleck’s “kiss” with another woman.
- Spring has arrived for “Captain Jack Sparrow” Johnny Depp as he unexpectedly went public with his latest young lover.
Is John Sugden Hiding a Dark Secret?
As Aaron and John’s storyline unfolds, Emmerdale fans are bracing for more shocking revelations. Is John a protective partner—or a cold-blooded killer?
Catch Emmerdale weeknights on ITVX. Do you think John’s hiding something sinister? Share your thoughts in the comments!
