Jonathan Haidt’s book The Anxious Generation: How the Great Rewiring of Childhood is Causing an Epidemic of Mental Illness has stirred significant debate on teen social media use. Haidt argues that Generation Z, who have grown up with smartphones, is experiencing heightened anxiety, depression, and self-harm rates, especially among adolescent girls, due to constant social media exposure. Organizations like the American Psychological Association and U.S. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy have echoed similar concerns, emphasizing social media’s impact on teens’ mental health.
(image: getty images)
A Crisis of Connection or Overreaction?
Haidt’s findings suggest that social media became a driving force of teenage anxiety around 2010–2015, when platforms like Instagram gained traction. He links the shift in teen mental health to increased social media usage, pointing to data showing that U.S. teens reporting major depressive episodes have more than doubled since 2010. This “rewiring of childhood” hypothesis suggests that online interaction has replaced in-person socializing, creating new pressures and affecting how young people connect with peers and family.
Read more: Top 3 Supplements You’re Wasting Money On: Insights from a Pharmacist
Critics Weigh In on the Debate
Not all experts agree with Haidt’s conclusions. Critics argue that his evidence primarily shows correlation, not causation. Oxford professor Andrew Przybylski highlights that Haidt’s claims require more robust evidence, while other researchers argue that mental health issues are not exclusive to teens, suggesting that social media may not be the primary cause. This skepticism underscores the broader debate: are we facing a crisis unique to today’s youth, or are we simply in a new phase of moral panic over technology?
Read more: How to Keep Your Teen Safe on TikTok: A Guide for Parents
Social Media’s Role in Adolescent Mental Health
Despite the criticism, Haidt maintains that social media’s “addictive qualities” play a central role in rising mental health concerns. He argues that platforms are designed to captivate young users, leading to compulsive behavior that can erode self-esteem and contribute to anxiety. Haidt’s research team continues to study these trends, using both data analysis and firsthand accounts from teens, parents, and teachers to support their case.
Read more: New Ultrasound Brain Treatment Shows Promise in Tackling Addiction
Navigating Forward
Whether it’s a true crisis or a societal overreaction, The Anxious Generation encourages parents and policymakers to consider limits on social media usage for teens. The debate highlights the need for awareness of digital health and balanced approaches to social media in youth life.
Stay informed on social media’s effects—follow us for the latest insights and updates.
